Are You Getting Stronger – Or Just Getting Better at the Same Workout?

Are You Getting Stronger – Or Just Getting Better at the Same Workout?

Consistency is one of the most important parts of strength training. Turning up regularly, doing your workouts and making exercise part of your routine is a huge achievement. If you’ve been using the same weights, doing the same number of repetitions and everything now feels quite comfortable, it might be time to ask yourself an important question: Am I actually getting stronger or have I just got very good at doing this particular workout?

Whether you’re new to strength training or have been doing it for a while, a particular exercise or weight might feel challenging. Your muscles have to work hard to complete the repetitions and, with regular training, your body begins to adapt. Over time, you become stronger. While that’s progress, to continue developing strength, we need to increase the challenge. This is known as progressive overload – as you get stronger, your training needs to progress with you.

Getting Comfortable Isn’t Always a Good Thing

Think back to when you first started strength training. Those first few sets of squats that left your legs feeling tired or you struggled to complete the final repetitions of your bicep curls. Fast forward a few months and you might be doing exactly the same exercises with the same weights, only now they feel considerably easier. It’s important to note that while this is signs of progress, just because you’re completing your workouts regularly doesn’t necessarily mean you’re continuing to develop strength at the same rate.

If your muscles are no longer being challenged sufficiently, there’s less reason for them to keep improving. You might be maintaining the strength you’ve already built, but if your goal is to continue getting stronger, you need to give your muscles a reason to do so.

Does That Mean I Have to Keep Lifting Heavier?

Not necessarily… Increasing your weights is one of the simplest ways to make an exercise more challenging, but it’s certainly not the only way to progress. There are plenty of ways to keep challenging your muscles without automatically reaching for heavier dumbbells. Sometimes even a small adjustment to an exercise can make a noticeable difference, particularly if you’ve been doing the same movements for a while.

Here are a few ways you can continue to challenge yourself:

  • Increase your repetitions. If you’ve been comfortably completing 10 squats with a particular weight, try gradually working towards 12. Those extra repetitions can help increase the challenge without changing your dumbbells.
  • Add another set. Completing an additional set increases the total amount of work your muscles perform and can be a simple way to progress when your current workout starts to feel easier.
  • Improve your range of movement. Perhaps you can squat a little deeper or move through a greater range during an exercise, provided you can maintain good technique and control throughout.
  • Slow things down. Rather than rushing through your repetitions, try slowing down the lowering phase of an exercise. Taking your time and controlling the movement can make even a familiar weight feel more challenging.
  • Try a more challenging variation. If you’ve been doing press-ups against a wall, perhaps you’re ready to try them using a lower surface. As your strength and confidence improve, you can gradually progress to more demanding versions of an exercise.
  • Focus on your technique. Better control, positioning and movement quality can make an exercise more effective. Sometimes it’s not about doing more, but about doing what you’re already doing better.

The important thing is to make these changes gradually. You don’t need to increase your weights, add more repetitions and complete an extra set all at once. Small, manageable changes over time are what we’re looking for, giving your muscles a new challenge while allowing you to maintain good technique and recover properly.

Progressive overload doesn’t mean making every workout harder.. It means recognising when your body is ready for a little more challenge.

Ladies, Don’t Be Afraid of Your Heavier Weights!

I think this is particularly important for women because there can still be a reluctance to increase weights, even when we’re perfectly capable of doing so. Sometimes it’s the fear of becoming bulky, sometimes it’s a lack of confidence or the belief that we should be sticking to lighter weights as we get older.

Repeat after me – picking up a heavier pair of dumbbells isn’t suddenly going to make you bulky! Building significant amounts of muscle takes time and consistent, dedicated training. Increasing your weights gradually is simply one way of encouraging your muscles to become stronger.

So how do you know when you’re ready to go heavier? This is something I’m asked ALL the time and my advice is to pay attention to how those final few repetitions feel. If you’re doing 10 repetitions and finish feeling as though you could easily manage another five or six, perhaps those weights aren’t challenging you enough anymore. Ideally, towards the end of a set, you should feel that you’re having to work. Those final few repetitions should require some effort, but you should still be able to complete them with good technique and control. There’s a BIG difference between challenging yourself and struggling to lift a weight that’s simply too heavy.

And remember, you won’t necessarily use the same weights for every exercise. Your legs and glutes can generally handle more resistance than smaller muscle groups, so the weights you use for squats during a Wednesday class for example are likely to be quite different from those you use for upper body during our Tuesday class on Caroline’s Circuits..

It’s also very important to stop comparing ourselves with other people. Your heavy is YOUR heavy. We all have different levels of strength, experience and confidence and the weights that are right for you will change as you get stronger. So if you’ve been reaching for the same pair of dumbbells for months and those final few repetitions are starting to feel a little too comfortable, don’t automatically assume you need to stick with them.

You Don’t Need to Keep Changing Your Workouts

There’s a tendency in fitness to think we constantly need new exercises to keep getting results. With so many different workouts and exercise variations available, it’s easy to assume that doing something new must be better than repeating the same familiar movements. But that’s not necessarily the case – repeating exercises is one of the best ways to develop strength because it gives you an opportunity to practise the movement, improve your technique and recognise whether you’re making progress.

Think about a squat. When you first start, you might be concentrating on your balance, how far you’re lowering yourself and maintaining good positioning. As you become more familiar with the movement, your technique improves and you begin to feel more confident. Eventually, you might find you’re able to squat deeper, complete more repetitions or use a heavier weight.

It’s much easier to recognise when you’re repeating exercises regularly rather than constantly changing them. Of course, variety has its place. Trying different exercises can keep your workouts interesting, challenge your muscles in different ways and help you stay motivated. But there’s no need to abandon an effective exercise simply because you’ve been doing it for a while. Squats don’t suddenly stop working because you’ve been doing them for six months. Neither do lunges, rows or presses for example. The question isn’t whether you’ve done an exercise before. It’s whether that exercise is still challenging you appropriately.

Sometimes you don’t need a completely new workout. You just need to find a way to make the one you’re doing a little more challenging.

Progress Isn’t Always About the Number on the Dumbbell

Although we’ve talked a lot about increasing weights, I don’t want you to think that lifting heavier is the only way to measure your progress. One of the things I love about strength training is that improvements can show themselves in so many different ways, and they’re not always immediately obvious.

Perhaps a weight that once felt incredibly heavy now feels manageable. Maybe you can complete more repetitions without stopping, or your balance and stability have improved during lunges. You might notice that your movements feel more controlled, your technique is better or you’re able to complete a full press-up when you previously needed to use your knees.

These might seem like small things, but they’re brilliant examples of how the strength you’re building during your workouts can make a real difference during your normal daily routine too. The interesting thing is that we don’t always notice these changes because they happen so gradually. There isn’t necessarily a moment when you suddenly realise how much stronger you’ve become. Often, it’s only when you think back to what you used to find difficult that you appreciate how far you’ve come. So don’t just focus on the number written on your dumbbells. Pay attention to your technique, your balance, your confidence and the everyday activities that are becoming easier.

More Isn’t Always Better

Now, before you rush off and start increasing all your weights, there’s something else worth remembering. Progressive overload doesn’t mean you should be pushing yourself harder every single time you exercise. You don’t need to increase your weights every week, add more repetitions to every exercise or finish every workout feeling completely exhausted.

In fact, doing too much without allowing enough time to recover can work against you. Your muscles need time to recover and adapt following training. Rest days, good nutrition and adequate sleep all play an important role in helping you build strength. If you’re constantly increasing the pressure on your body without giving it enough opportunity to recover, you may find yourself feeling more tired and performing less well rather than getting stronger.

The goal isn’t to do more every time. It’s to gradually become capable of doing more over time.

A Final Thought

If there’s one thing I’d love you to take away from this, it’s that consistency and progression go hand in hand. Turning up regularly and making strength training part of your routine is a fantastic achievement, it’s also important to recognise when you’re ready to take that next small step.

Think back to the weights you were using six months ago. Remember the exercises you used to find difficult and the repetitions that felt like a real challenge. Now think about how those same exercises feel today. If they’re easier, brilliant, but don’t let that progress become the reason you stop challenging yourself. You don’t need to completely change your workouts or start lifting dramatically heavier weights. Add an extra couple of repetitio a little more control, a deeper squat or an additional set. Or maybe it’s simply time to reach for those heavier dumbbells you’ve been avoiding! So next time you start your workout, ask yourself: Am I choosing these weights because they’re a safe choice, or do I want to challenge myself?

You’ve already proved that you can get stronger. Now give yourself the opportunity to see just how much stronger you can become.

As always, if you have any questions, please do get in touch.

Caroline x

Got 10 Minutes? Why Short Bursts of Movement Matter

Got 10 Minutes? Why Short Bursts of Movement Matter

Nervous About Strength Training? Let’s Make It Less Intimidating

Nervous About Strength Training? Let’s Make It Less Intimidating

Why Fat Around the Tummy Can Be Harder to Shift in Midlife

Why Fat Around the Tummy Can Be Harder to Shift in Midlife